4 Comments
User's avatar
Martin Murray's avatar

Do you have any data to back that up besides an eyeball "correlation"? Charlotte and Jackson murders are up while NYC and Baltimore murders are bottoming out. Even being as generous as possible I don't see it

Mark Thompson's avatar

There seems to be a pretty strong correlation between the strength of the positive change and the political party controlling the pertinent Statehouse. Since that factor is also highly correlated with whether the state and local law enforcement cooperates with ICE, that suggests a meaningful amount of the drop is due to ICE operations, and/or the deterrent effect thereof.

Wigan's avatar

GOP in control:

2018-19: very little change

2019-20: big rise

Dems in control:

2020-21: big rise

2021-22: very little change

2022-23: decrease starting

2023-24: decrease accelerating

GOP in control

2024-25: decrease continues

2025-26: decrease continues

I don't really see the strong correlation you are seeing.

Tom Durkin's avatar

And since the changes from a November election don't take place until mid-January of the next year, that seems to weaken the suggested correlation.